]> dreyeck.freedombox.rocks Git - topic-maps.git/blob - reports/slice-22a/normative-review.json
Integrate qualified XML anyType values into the XTM reader
[topic-maps.git] / reports / slice-22a / normative-review.json
1 {
2 "kind": "reviewed-normative-and-source-evidence-not-conformance-certification",
3 "reviewDate": "2026-10-20",
4 "sources": {
5 "CTM": {
6 "edition": "ISO/IEC 13250-6:2010",
7 "url": "https://www.isotopicmaps.org/ctm/ctm.html",
8 "evidenceLimit": "Public HTML mirror; published 2010 preview confirms through 3.4.2, not full 3.9/3.14-3.16. Corpus targets draft 2010-03-31."
9 },
10 "XTM": {
11 "edition": "ISO/IEC 13250-3:2007 / XTM 2.0",
12 "url": "https://www.isotopicmaps.org/sam/sam-xtm/",
13 "evidenceLimit": "2006-06-19 public mirror explicitly states identity with published standard; ISO publication remains authoritative."
14 },
15 "TMDM": {
16 "edition": "ISO/IEC 13250-2:2006",
17 "url": "https://www.isotopicmaps.org/sam/sam-model/2006-06-18/",
18 "evidenceLimit": "Mirror states identity with publication; model has no standalone processor conformance section (1)."
19 },
20 "CXTM": {
21 "edition": "ISO/IEC 13250-4:2009",
22 "url": "https://www.isotopicmaps.org/cxtm/cxtm.html",
23 "evidenceLimit": "Public 2009-01-27 mirror; final edition/errata equivalence is a closure review obligation."
24 },
25 "XSD": {
26 "edition": "XML Schema 1.0 Part 2, Second Edition, 2004-10-28",
27 "url": "https://www.w3.org/TR/2004/REC-xmlschema-2-20041028/",
28 "evidenceLimit": "Dated primary W3C Recommendation; no substitution of XSD 1.1."
29 },
30 "CTM-published-preview": {
31 "edition": "ISO/IEC 13250-6:2010(E), first edition 2010-11-15, 11-page preview",
32 "url": "https://cdn.standards.iteh.ai/samples/43940/6663ee28c1604551ac6adc02e22c6bb6/ISO-IEC-13250-6-2010.pdf",
33 "evidenceLimit": "Public published sample inspected online only; later clauses/complete grammar unavailable in preview. No local download."
34 },
35 "CanonicalXML": {
36 "edition": "W3C Canonical XML 1.0, Recommendation 2001-03-15",
37 "url": "https://www.w3.org/TR/2001/REC-xml-c14n-20010315",
38 "sections": "2.1–2.4; node-set and comment flag; XTM 4.16.3 determines use",
39 "evidenceLimit": "Primary W3C source; existing CXML :canonical option has not been qualified as this algorithm for the required XTM subset."
40 }
41 },
42 "localNormSnapshotsDownloaded": false,
43 "epistemicLabels": {
44 "observed": "Fresh execution or identified local source bytes",
45 "derived": "Reasoning from cited clauses, qualified by source edition limits",
46 "inferred": "Implementation-scope/dependency judgment from inspected code",
47 "hypothesized": "Historical extension intent without documentary proof",
48 "proposed": "Future acceptance; not implemented or authorized by this investigation"
49 },
50 "decisions": {
51 "ctmInclude": "C, previous B interpretation plausible under HTML, full published clauses not verified",
52 "ctmDateTime": "B supported by XSD 1.0/CXTM rules, final CXTM edition/errata qualification remains",
53 "ctmTemplateTail": "Excluded by inspected HTML grammar, formal edition decision C; no language extension",
54 "xtmMapItemID": "Tentative baseline conflict, decision C, XTM 4.21 only topics/associations",
55 "xtmMapLoop": "Decision C, finite cycle semantics need qualification"
56 },
57 "xmlPreflight": {
58 "path": "/nix/store/5075y4alv1is8n78bcsfcaj0mfpqz195-source/xml/unparse.lisp",
59 "sha256": "cef774a7a6a90b970e99939d923c4e564ecf903a7cfa72f4498356ee8253e87c",
60 "lines": "165–202",
61 "finding": "Existing canonical writer options are a capability to qualify, not proof of W3C Canonical XML 1.0 subset compliance.",
62 "readerSource": "src/xtm/reader.lisp",
63 "findingSourceHandler": "Current XML source nodes retain expanded names/attributes/text/children/positions, but not the full qualified-name/namespace context needed to select namespace nodes for XTM 4.16.3. That clause selects descendant element/attribute/character nodes; PI nodes are not selected, comments are excluded."
64 }
65 }