]> dreyeck.freedombox.rocks Git - topic-maps.git/blob - docs/slice-22c-original-evidence.md
Implement XTM role reification with native conformance evidence
[topic-maps.git] / docs / slice-22c-original-evidence.md
1 # Slice 22C — Originale, Baselines und tatsächliche Beobachtungen
2
3 Generiert aus der erneut geprüften fallbezogenen Evidenz. [Entscheidungen und Editionsgrenzen](slice-22c-normative-decisions.md); [vollständige JSON-Evidenz](../reports/slice-22c/case-evidence.json).
4
5 Quellbytes, Hashes und Prozessresultate sind `observed`; grammatische Rollen sind `derived`, historische Argumentabsichten `inferred`. Zeichenpositionen sind nullbasiert, Zeile/Spalte einsbasiert. XTM-Positionen bleiben die ungefähr gemeldeten SAX-Positionen. Die Lesefassung blendet Leerraum am Zeilenende aus; Text und Hexwerte im JSON erhalten sämtliche Originalbytes einschließlich BOM und fehlendem Schluss-LF.
6
7 ## ctm/in/include-template.ctm
8
9 Vorher: unresolved-requirement / C. Neue Entscheidung: **C**. Registrierung unverändert: `fail`.
10
11 Document IRI: `https://ctm-tests.example.invalid/cd165b150176c1d6842b37be9cc9051b40d4996b/ctm/in/include-template.ctm`.
12
13 Original: `vendor/cxtm/ctm/in/include-template.ctm`, 48 Bytes; SHA-256 `345ee0e00a096195979bdc64cc8aad272e5c60ebeee185c69c4223b5c911f674`.
14
15 ```text
16 %include <include-template.sub>
17
18 template(topic)
19 ```
20
21 Quellabschluss: kein abschließendes LF. UTF-8-BOM: nein.
22
23 Unveränderte Baseline: `vendor/cxtm/ctm/baseline/include-template.ctm.cxtm`, 401 Bytes; SHA-256 `ebf9e7acc9dd9487ebf19c9f2dc1c8af3933e0371d9a506eee307923c5d65d0c`.
24
25 ```xml
26 <topicMap>
27 <topic number="1">
28 <itemIdentifiers>
29 <locator>#topic</locator>
30 </itemIdentifiers>
31 <occurrence number="1">
32 <value>Test</value>
33 <datatype>http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema#string</datatype>
34 <type topicref="2"></type>
35 </occurrence>
36 </topic>
37 <topic number="2">
38 <itemIdentifiers>
39 <locator>#occtype</locator>
40 <locator>include-template.sub#occtype</locator>
41 </itemIdentifiers>
42 </topic>
43 </topicMap>
44 ```
45
46 Tatsächliche Condition (einschließlich Code, Position und Cause):
47
48 ```json
49 null
50 ```
51
52 Ist-CXTM: 353 Bytes, SHA-256 `15326a49da9e44f4a3f886414aa2134cf3ba0f7682bb52259e3b64138ac5e864`. Vollständiger Bytevergleich: **nicht identisch**. Erste Differenz: 58.
53
54 ```xml
55 <topicMap>
56 <topic number="1">
57 <itemIdentifiers>
58 <locator>#occtype</locator>
59 </itemIdentifiers>
60 </topic>
61 <topic number="2">
62 <itemIdentifiers>
63 <locator>#topic</locator>
64 </itemIdentifiers>
65 <occurrence number="1">
66 <value>Test</value>
67 <datatype>http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema#string</datatype>
68 <type topicref="1"></type>
69 </occurrence>
70 </topic>
71 </topicMap>
72 ```
73
74 Verbleibende Modelldifferenzen nach Identitätszuordnung:
75
76 ```json
77 [
78 {
79 "path": "/children/0/children/0/children",
80 "actual": [
81 {
82 "element": "locator",
83 "attributes": {},
84 "text": "#occtype",
85 "children": []
86 }
87 ],
88 "expected": [
89 {
90 "element": "locator",
91 "attributes": {},
92 "text": "#occtype",
93 "children": []
94 },
95 {
96 "element": "locator",
97 "attributes": {},
98 "text": "include-template.sub#occtype",
99 "children": []
100 }
101 ]
102 }
103 ]
104 ```
105
106 Unveränderte Hilfsquelle: `vendor/cxtm/ctm/in/include-template.sub`, 52 Bytes; SHA-256 `d40daa6f573eac03e72c45ee8d018a23bffa97f0dcc28d4bcd481a7e5d11205f`.
107
108 ```text
109
110 def template($topic)
111 $topic occtype: "Test".
112 end
113 ```
114
115 Neue normative Entscheidung und offene Primärquellen:
116
117 ```json
118 {
119 "classification": "C",
120 "scope": "Definition/import/invocation environment and extra definition-source II",
121 "claim": "The current model contains only caller-document identifiers. Whether the published later clauses require the baseline extra II is not established.",
122 "conditionalConclusion": "B is supported by the inspected HTML interpretation; no eager Topic exists in the observed child.",
123 "references": [
124 "CTM-HTML:3.2,3.14–3.16.2",
125 "CTM-PREVIEW",
126 "TMDM-HTML:5.1,5.2,6.2"
127 ],
128 "openQuestions": [
129 "Q-CTM",
130 "Q-ERRATA"
131 ],
132 "nextAction": "Verify declaration vs invocation environment before proposing any identifier change.",
133 "epistemicStatus": "derived",
134 "evidenceStrength": "explicit missing primary clause or interpretation; bounded conclusion from available sources"
135 }
136 ```
137
138 ## ctm/in/include-wildcard2.ctm
139
140 Vorher: unresolved-requirement / C. Neue Entscheidung: **C**. Registrierung unverändert: `fail`.
141
142 Document IRI: `https://ctm-tests.example.invalid/cd165b150176c1d6842b37be9cc9051b40d4996b/ctm/in/include-wildcard2.ctm`.
143
144 Original: `vendor/cxtm/ctm/in/include-wildcard2.ctm`, 50 Bytes; SHA-256 `1e55e65bad772df558b27e9566b06e3529392983a18f9d9fc1d73518d85597c9`.
145
146 ```text
147 %include <include-wildcard2.sub>
148
149 ?foo - "Master".
150 ```
151
152 Quellabschluss: kein abschließendes LF. UTF-8-BOM: nein.
153
154 Unveränderte Baseline: `vendor/cxtm/ctm/baseline/include-wildcard2.ctm.cxtm`, 669 Bytes; SHA-256 `cd55c6eb2fe686d73209d074ee42b576d0fdeab5efcc62f3beff24ced69ba327`.
155
156 ```xml
157 <topicMap>
158 <topic number="1">
159 <itemIdentifiers>
160 <locator>#$__1.foo</locator>
161 </itemIdentifiers>
162 <name number="1">
163 <value>Sub Sub</value>
164 <type topicref="4"></type>
165 </name>
166 </topic>
167 <topic number="2">
168 <itemIdentifiers>
169 <locator>#$__2.foo</locator>
170 </itemIdentifiers>
171 <name number="1">
172 <value>Sub</value>
173 <type topicref="4"></type>
174 </name>
175 </topic>
176 <topic number="3">
177 <itemIdentifiers>
178 <locator>#$__3.foo</locator>
179 </itemIdentifiers>
180 <name number="1">
181 <value>Master</value>
182 <type topicref="4"></type>
183 </name>
184 </topic>
185 <topic number="4">
186 <subjectIdentifiers>
187 <locator>http://psi.topicmaps.org/iso13250/model/topic-name</locator>
188 </subjectIdentifiers>
189 </topic>
190 </topicMap>
191 ```
192
193 Tatsächliche Condition (einschließlich Code, Position und Cause):
194
195 ```json
196 null
197 ```
198
199 Ist-CXTM: 719 Bytes, SHA-256 `be6e7114120452715b740956b25d8c1ec263814d2210e6ea323976055ecc082e`. Vollständiger Bytevergleich: **nicht identisch**. Erste Differenz: 61.
200
201 ```xml
202 <topicMap>
203 <topic number="1">
204 <itemIdentifiers>
205 <locator>#$__2.foo</locator>
206 </itemIdentifiers>
207 <name number="1">
208 <value>Sub</value>
209 <type topicref="4"></type>
210 </name>
211 </topic>
212 <topic number="2">
213 <itemIdentifiers>
214 <locator>#$__3.foo</locator>
215 </itemIdentifiers>
216 <name number="1">
217 <value>Master</value>
218 <type topicref="4"></type>
219 </name>
220 </topic>
221 <topic number="3">
222 <itemIdentifiers>
223 <locator>#$__1.foo</locator>
224 <locator>include-wildcard2.sub#$__1.foo</locator>
225 </itemIdentifiers>
226 <name number="1">
227 <value>Sub Sub</value>
228 <type topicref="4"></type>
229 </name>
230 </topic>
231 <topic number="4">
232 <subjectIdentifiers>
233 <locator>http://psi.topicmaps.org/iso13250/model/topic-name</locator>
234 </subjectIdentifiers>
235 </topic>
236 </topicMap>
237 ```
238
239 Verbleibende Modelldifferenzen nach Identitätszuordnung:
240
241 ```json
242 [
243 {
244 "path": "/children/0/children/0/children",
245 "actual": [
246 {
247 "element": "locator",
248 "attributes": {},
249 "text": "#$__1.foo",
250 "children": []
251 },
252 {
253 "element": "locator",
254 "attributes": {},
255 "text": "include-wildcard2.sub#$__1.foo",
256 "children": []
257 }
258 ],
259 "expected": [
260 {
261 "element": "locator",
262 "attributes": {},
263 "text": "#$__1.foo",
264 "children": []
265 }
266 ]
267 }
268 ]
269 ```
270
271 Unveränderte Hilfsquelle: `vendor/cxtm/ctm/in/include-wildcard2.sub`, 49 Bytes; SHA-256 `d715a10dfd9fc01f0d37397d0ecf36ca169902144f6091d5e7ca036598d63efd`.
272
273 ```text
274 %include <include-wildcard2.sub2>
275
276 ?foo - "Sub".
277 ```
278
279 Unveränderte Hilfsquelle: `vendor/cxtm/ctm/in/include-wildcard2.sub2`, 19 Bytes; SHA-256 `c78cc6ff88b6b04cddc5703f502783f3c739d082b744db21f10d2393c36a2a3d`.
280
281 ```text
282
283 ?foo - "Sub Sub".
284 ```
285
286 Neue normative Entscheidung und offene Primärquellen:
287
288 ```json
289 {
290 "classification": "C",
291 "scope": "Retention of nested include wildcard item identifier",
292 "claim": "The child-origin II remains in the observed map, whereas the baseline omits it. Its removal is not justified by the inspected text.",
293 "conditionalConclusion": "B under inspected HTML; publication-equivalent include text still needed.",
294 "references": [
295 "CTM-HTML:3.2,3.3.8,3.16.2",
296 "CTM-PREVIEW",
297 "TMDM-HTML:5.1,6.1–6.2"
298 ],
299 "openQuestions": [
300 "Q-CTM",
301 "Q-ERRATA"
302 ],
303 "nextAction": "Verify the exact published include identifier operation; preserve both observed identifiers meanwhile.",
304 "epistemicStatus": "derived",
305 "evidenceStrength": "explicit missing primary clause or interpretation; bounded conclusion from available sources"
306 }
307 ```
308
309 ## ctm/in/occurrence-datetime-timezone2.ctm
310
311 Vorher: normative-conflict / B. Neue Entscheidung: **C**. Registrierung unverändert: `fail`.
312
313 Document IRI: `https://ctm-tests.example.invalid/cd165b150176c1d6842b37be9cc9051b40d4996b/ctm/in/occurrence-datetime-timezone2.ctm`.
314
315 Original: `vendor/cxtm/ctm/in/occurrence-datetime-timezone2.ctm`, 92 Bytes; SHA-256 `4240411defe0618e6a6431d624cfbe480607e4d15c83c10d0c6a5a85c2fafa7c`.
316
317 ```text
318 datetime - "datetime" .
319
320 some-topic - "some topic" ;
321 datetime: 2011-01-01T00:00:00+02:00
322 .
323 ```
324
325 Quellabschluss: kein abschließendes LF. UTF-8-BOM: nein.
326
327 Unveränderte Baseline: `vendor/cxtm/ctm/baseline/occurrence-datetime-timezone2.ctm.cxtm`, 679 Bytes; SHA-256 `fe840f8b3a6a7b068d08592373ab71ebe757f6d3e03c0bee792deab74b6b6080`.
328
329 ```xml
330 <topicMap>
331 <topic number="1">
332 <itemIdentifiers>
333 <locator>#datetime</locator>
334 </itemIdentifiers>
335 <name number="1">
336 <value>datetime</value>
337 <type topicref="3"></type>
338 </name>
339 </topic>
340 <topic number="2">
341 <itemIdentifiers>
342 <locator>#some-topic</locator>
343 </itemIdentifiers>
344 <name number="1">
345 <value>some topic</value>
346 <type topicref="3"></type>
347 </name>
348 <occurrence number="1">
349 <value>2011-01-01T00:00:00+02:00</value>
350 <datatype>http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema#dateTime</datatype>
351 <type topicref="1"></type>
352 </occurrence>
353 </topic>
354 <topic number="3">
355 <subjectIdentifiers>
356 <locator>http://psi.topicmaps.org/iso13250/model/topic-name</locator>
357 </subjectIdentifiers>
358 </topic>
359 </topicMap>
360 ```
361
362 Tatsächliche Condition (einschließlich Code, Position und Cause):
363
364 ```json
365 null
366 ```
367
368 Ist-CXTM: 674 Bytes, SHA-256 `b15755d77327c002ae1e3c75c0fa8ac2de7f50f6175153012e0e88d8ba86dcff`. Vollständiger Bytevergleich: **nicht identisch**. Erste Differenz: 382.
369
370 ```xml
371 <topicMap>
372 <topic number="1">
373 <itemIdentifiers>
374 <locator>#datetime</locator>
375 </itemIdentifiers>
376 <name number="1">
377 <value>datetime</value>
378 <type topicref="3"></type>
379 </name>
380 </topic>
381 <topic number="2">
382 <itemIdentifiers>
383 <locator>#some-topic</locator>
384 </itemIdentifiers>
385 <name number="1">
386 <value>some topic</value>
387 <type topicref="3"></type>
388 </name>
389 <occurrence number="1">
390 <value>2010-12-31T22:00:00Z</value>
391 <datatype>http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema#dateTime</datatype>
392 <type topicref="1"></type>
393 </occurrence>
394 </topic>
395 <topic number="3">
396 <subjectIdentifiers>
397 <locator>http://psi.topicmaps.org/iso13250/model/topic-name</locator>
398 </subjectIdentifiers>
399 </topic>
400 </topicMap>
401 ```
402
403 Verbleibende Modelldifferenzen nach Identitätszuordnung:
404
405 ```json
406 [
407 {
408 "path": "/children/1/children/2/children/0/text",
409 "actual": "2010-12-31T22:00:00Z",
410 "expected": "2011-01-01T00:00:00+02:00"
411 }
412 ]
413 ```
414
415 Neue normative Entscheidung und offene Primärquellen:
416
417 ```json
418 {
419 "classification": "C",
420 "scope": "Final ISO CXTM edition decision; XSD-level conclusion separately supported",
421 "claim": "Current value/canonical bytes have direct XSD support and contradict the public-CXTM reading of the historical baseline. Final B requires the unavailable published CXTM clause.",
422 "conditionalConclusion": "B under CXTM-HTML plus XSD-2004; this is not an unconditional ISO-edition B.",
423 "references": [
424 "CTM-PREVIEW:3.4.1 printed p.5",
425 "CXTM-HTML:2,3.16",
426 "XSD-2004:3.2.7.1–3.2.7.3,D.1,E.1",
427 "XSD-ERRATA"
428 ],
429 "openQuestions": [
430 "Q-CXTM",
431 "Q-ERRATA"
432 ],
433 "nextAction": "Retain FAIL; verify published CXTM 3.16, then separately approve a documented baseline exception, never rewrite the original baseline.",
434 "changeFrom22A": "Tightens earlier edition-qualified B to formal C; observations and XSD reasoning are unchanged, but missing final CXTM clause is now a decision gate.",
435 "epistemicStatus": "derived",
436 "evidenceStrength": "explicit missing primary clause or interpretation; bounded conclusion from available sources"
437 }
438 ```
439
440 ## ctm/in/occurrence-datetime2.ctm
441
442 Vorher: normative-conflict / B. Neue Entscheidung: **C**. Registrierung unverändert: `fail`.
443
444 Document IRI: `https://ctm-tests.example.invalid/cd165b150176c1d6842b37be9cc9051b40d4996b/ctm/in/occurrence-datetime2.ctm`.
445
446 Original: `vendor/cxtm/ctm/in/occurrence-datetime2.ctm`, 122 Bytes; SHA-256 `75f6b381203abd7ffb0d0a398abb4ad2aea10b676772d54e8086adf52df88ab1`.
447
448 ```text
449 #
450 # Test for leap seconds,
451 # c.f. <http://projects.topicmapslab.de/issues/2563>
452 #
453 topic
454 occtype: 1976-09-19T12:01:60 .
455 ```
456
457 Quellabschluss: kein abschließendes LF. UTF-8-BOM: ja.
458
459 Unveränderte Baseline: `vendor/cxtm/ctm/baseline/occurrence-datetime2.ctm.cxtm`, 370 Bytes; SHA-256 `90bd6e740db72cb46a9fcee9329b70d0963bc6317300e498c941e00d9ff5c55f`.
460
461 ```xml
462 <topicMap>
463 <topic number="1">
464 <itemIdentifiers>
465 <locator>#occtype</locator>
466 </itemIdentifiers>
467 </topic>
468 <topic number="2">
469 <itemIdentifiers>
470 <locator>#topic</locator>
471 </itemIdentifiers>
472 <occurrence number="1">
473 <value>1976-09-19T12:01:60</value>
474 <datatype>http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema#dateTime</datatype>
475 <type topicref="1"></type>
476 </occurrence>
477 </topic>
478 </topicMap>
479 ```
480
481 Tatsächliche Condition (einschließlich Code, Position und Cause):
482
483 ```json
484 null
485 ```
486
487 Ist-CXTM: 370 Bytes, SHA-256 `2cdbdd98349a1f830ec2f49c2331d2c5220492c1d8b75563db8623ecb38e76fd`. Vollständiger Bytevergleich: **nicht identisch**. Erste Differenz: 232.
488
489 ```xml
490 <topicMap>
491 <topic number="1">
492 <itemIdentifiers>
493 <locator>#occtype</locator>
494 </itemIdentifiers>
495 </topic>
496 <topic number="2">
497 <itemIdentifiers>
498 <locator>#topic</locator>
499 </itemIdentifiers>
500 <occurrence number="1">
501 <value>1976-09-19T12:02:00</value>
502 <datatype>http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema#dateTime</datatype>
503 <type topicref="1"></type>
504 </occurrence>
505 </topic>
506 </topicMap>
507 ```
508
509 Verbleibende Modelldifferenzen nach Identitätszuordnung:
510
511 ```json
512 [
513 {
514 "path": "/children/1/children/1/children/0/text",
515 "actual": "1976-09-19T12:02:00",
516 "expected": "1976-09-19T12:01:60"
517 }
518 ]
519 ```
520
521 Neue normative Entscheidung und offene Primärquellen:
522
523 ```json
524 {
525 "classification": "C",
526 "scope": "Final ISO CXTM edition decision; XSD-level conclusion separately supported",
527 "claim": "Current value/canonical bytes have direct XSD support and contradict the public-CXTM reading of the historical baseline. Final B requires the unavailable published CXTM clause.",
528 "conditionalConclusion": "B under CXTM-HTML plus XSD-2004; this is not an unconditional ISO-edition B.",
529 "references": [
530 "CTM-PREVIEW:3.4.1 printed p.5",
531 "CXTM-HTML:2,3.16",
532 "XSD-2004:3.2.7.1–3.2.7.3,D.1,E.1",
533 "XSD-ERRATA"
534 ],
535 "openQuestions": [
536 "Q-CXTM",
537 "Q-ERRATA"
538 ],
539 "nextAction": "Retain FAIL; verify published CXTM 3.16, then separately approve a documented baseline exception, never rewrite the original baseline.",
540 "changeFrom22A": "Tightens earlier edition-qualified B to formal C; observations and XSD reasoning are unchanged, but missing final CXTM clause is now a decision gate.",
541 "epistemicStatus": "derived",
542 "evidenceStrength": "explicit missing primary clause or interpretation; bounded conclusion from available sources"
543 }
544 ```
545
546 ## ctm/in/template-ambiguous-parameter5.ctm
547
548 Vorher: normative-conflict / C. Neue Entscheidung: **C**. Registrierung unverändert: `not-run`.
549
550 Document IRI: `https://ctm-tests.example.invalid/cd165b150176c1d6842b37be9cc9051b40d4996b/ctm/in/template-ambiguous-parameter5.ctm`.
551
552 Original: `vendor/cxtm/ctm/in/template-ambiguous-parameter5.ctm`, 146 Bytes; SHA-256 `5a4310d6f077776996700a77cd037ca30b1b616f7235128f9500ef16c5cd78a8`.
553
554 ```text
555
556 # Using an IRI argument in different contexts
557
558 def template($iri)
559 topic $iri; =$iri; ^$iri.
560 end
561
562 template(<http://www.example.org/something/>)
563 ```
564
565 Quellabschluss: LF vorhanden. UTF-8-BOM: nein.
566
567 Unveränderte Baseline: `vendor/cxtm/ctm/baseline/template-ambiguous-parameter5.ctm.cxtm`, 353 Bytes; SHA-256 `a90bb867d36b9d99061d3815c6ce41a1cd4d8909c49adc7ce9cc1c9bfe06303f`.
568
569 ```xml
570 <topicMap>
571 <topic number="1">
572 <subjectIdentifiers>
573 <locator>http://www.example.org/something/</locator>
574 </subjectIdentifiers>
575 <subjectLocators>
576 <locator>http://www.example.org/something/</locator>
577 </subjectLocators>
578 <itemIdentifiers>
579 <locator>#topic</locator>
580 <locator>http://www.example.org/something/</locator>
581 </itemIdentifiers>
582 </topic>
583 </topicMap>
584 ```
585
586 Tatsächliche Condition (einschließlich Code, Position und Cause):
587
588 ```json
589 {
590 "condition": "INVALID-TEMPLATE-BODY",
591 "message": "TEMPLATE-IDENTITY-TAIL in ctm/in/template-ambiguous-parameter5.ctm at CHARACTER 79 (line 5, column 13): Unmarked variable identities in Topic Tails remain outside the supported grammar.",
592 "code": "template-identity-tail",
593 "position": 79,
594 "line": 5,
595 "column": 13,
596 "positionUnit": "character",
597 "source": "ctm/in/template-ambiguous-parameter5.ctm",
598 "cause": null,
599 "context": null
600 }
601 ```
602
603 Kein natives Original-Ergebnismodell und keine Original-Ist-CXTM-Ausgabe; keine Ersatzmap konstruiert.
604
605 Erneut geprüfte Variablenpositionen, Deklaration, Aufrufe und Bindungen:
606
607 ```json
608 {
609 "variables": [
610 {
611 "variable": "$iri",
612 "position": 61,
613 "line": 4,
614 "column": 14,
615 "role": "Parameterdeklaration"
616 },
617 {
618 "variable": "$iri",
619 "position": 75,
620 "line": 5,
621 "column": 9,
622 "role": "Subject Identifier im Topic Tail (unmarkiert)"
623 },
624 {
625 "variable": "$iri",
626 "position": 82,
627 "line": 5,
628 "column": 16,
629 "role": "Subject Locator nach ="
630 },
631 {
632 "variable": "$iri",
633 "position": 89,
634 "line": 5,
635 "column": 23,
636 "role": "Item Identifier nach ^"
637 }
638 ],
639 "declaration": "def template($iri)",
640 "bindings": [
641 [
642 "$iri",
643 "<http://www.example.org/something/>"
644 ]
645 ],
646 "invocations": [
647 {
648 "text": "template(<http://www.example.org/something/>)",
649 "position": 100,
650 "line": 8
651 }
652 ]
653 }
654 ```
655
656 Ausgeschriebene Gegenprobe (kein Original-PASS): 353/353 Bytes identisch; Condition null.
657
658 Neue normative Entscheidung und offene Primärquellen:
659
660 ```json
661 {
662 "classification": "C",
663 "scope": "Published-edition legality of unmarked additional SI variable in Topic Tail",
664 "claim": "The inspected HTML excludes this body position. The current condition occurs there before argument qualification; later published grammar has not been verified.",
665 "conditionalConclusion": "Body invalid under inspected HTML. The expanded control reproduces baseline bytes but does not validate the original template.",
666 "references": [
667 "CTM-HTML:3.3.5–3.3.7,3.4,3.8–3.9,3.14–3.15",
668 "CTM-LANDING",
669 "CTM-PREVIEW"
670 ],
671 "openQuestions": [
672 "Q-CTM",
673 "Q-ERRATA"
674 ],
675 "nextAction": "Keep NOT-RUN. Decide any documented corpus exception only after edition check; compatibility grammar would need separate authorization.",
676 "historicalIntent": {
677 "epistemicStatus": "hypothesized",
678 "claim": "The corpus may have assumed variable substitution in an additional SI tail position; no editor decision/erratum proving that intention was found."
679 },
680 "epistemicStatus": "derived",
681 "evidenceStrength": "explicit missing primary clause or interpretation; bounded conclusion from available sources"
682 }
683 ```
684
685 ## ctm/in/template-ambiguous-parameter6.ctm
686
687 Vorher: normative-conflict / C. Neue Entscheidung: **C**. Registrierung unverändert: `not-run`.
688
689 Document IRI: `https://ctm-tests.example.invalid/cd165b150176c1d6842b37be9cc9051b40d4996b/ctm/in/template-ambiguous-parameter6.ctm`.
690
691 Original: `vendor/cxtm/ctm/in/template-ambiguous-parameter6.ctm`, 163 Bytes; SHA-256 `d2fd507bbbd544b6eae6caf4497c18e746165a5868a1d8e644eb18815db44d50`.
692
693 ```text
694
695 %prefix ex <http://www.example.org/>
696
697 # Using a QName argument in different contexts
698
699 def template($q)
700 topic $q; =$q; ^$q; occ: $q.
701 end
702
703 template(ex:something)
704 ```
705
706 Quellabschluss: LF vorhanden. UTF-8-BOM: nein.
707
708 Unveränderte Baseline: `vendor/cxtm/ctm/baseline/template-ambiguous-parameter6.ctm.cxtm`, 613 Bytes; SHA-256 `3b20e3168ad1260c2a4fcb2b5b4b0026324a78263f2431d6637473087eecd672`.
709
710 ```xml
711 <topicMap>
712 <topic number="1">
713 <itemIdentifiers>
714 <locator>#occ</locator>
715 </itemIdentifiers>
716 </topic>
717 <topic number="2">
718 <subjectIdentifiers>
719 <locator>http://www.example.org/something</locator>
720 </subjectIdentifiers>
721 <subjectLocators>
722 <locator>http://www.example.org/something</locator>
723 </subjectLocators>
724 <itemIdentifiers>
725 <locator>#topic</locator>
726 <locator>http://www.example.org/something</locator>
727 </itemIdentifiers>
728 <occurrence number="1">
729 <value>http://www.example.org/something</value>
730 <datatype>http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema#anyURI</datatype>
731 <type topicref="1"></type>
732 </occurrence>
733 </topic>
734 </topicMap>
735 ```
736
737 Tatsächliche Condition (einschließlich Code, Position und Cause):
738
739 ```json
740 {
741 "condition": "INVALID-TEMPLATE-BODY",
742 "message": "TEMPLATE-IDENTITY-TAIL in ctm/in/template-ambiguous-parameter6.ctm at CHARACTER 114 (line 7, column 11): Unmarked variable identities in Topic Tails remain outside the supported grammar.",
743 "code": "template-identity-tail",
744 "position": 114,
745 "line": 7,
746 "column": 11,
747 "positionUnit": "character",
748 "source": "ctm/in/template-ambiguous-parameter6.ctm",
749 "cause": null,
750 "context": null
751 }
752 ```
753
754 Kein natives Original-Ergebnismodell und keine Original-Ist-CXTM-Ausgabe; keine Ersatzmap konstruiert.
755
756 Erneut geprüfte Variablenpositionen, Deklaration, Aufrufe und Bindungen:
757
758 ```json
759 {
760 "variables": [
761 {
762 "variable": "$q",
763 "position": 100,
764 "line": 6,
765 "column": 14,
766 "role": "Parameterdeklaration"
767 },
768 {
769 "variable": "$q",
770 "position": 112,
771 "line": 7,
772 "column": 9,
773 "role": "Subject Identifier im Topic Tail (unmarkiert)"
774 },
775 {
776 "variable": "$q",
777 "position": 117,
778 "line": 7,
779 "column": 14,
780 "role": "Subject Locator nach ="
781 },
782 {
783 "variable": "$q",
784 "position": 122,
785 "line": 7,
786 "column": 19,
787 "role": "Item Identifier nach ^"
788 },
789 {
790 "variable": "$q",
791 "position": 131,
792 "line": 7,
793 "column": 28,
794 "role": "Occurrence-Literal; Datentyp xsd:anyURI"
795 }
796 ],
797 "declaration": "def template($q)",
798 "bindings": [
799 [
800 "$q",
801 "ex:something → http://www.example.org/something"
802 ]
803 ],
804 "invocations": [
805 {
806 "text": "template(ex:something)",
807 "position": 140,
808 "line": 10
809 }
810 ]
811 }
812 ```
813
814 Ausgeschriebene Gegenprobe (kein Original-PASS): 613/613 Bytes identisch; Condition null.
815
816 Neue normative Entscheidung und offene Primärquellen:
817
818 ```json
819 {
820 "classification": "C",
821 "scope": "Published-edition legality of unmarked additional SI variable in Topic Tail",
822 "claim": "The inspected HTML excludes this body position. The current condition occurs there before argument qualification; later published grammar has not been verified.",
823 "conditionalConclusion": "Body invalid under inspected HTML. The expanded control reproduces baseline bytes but does not validate the original template.",
824 "references": [
825 "CTM-HTML:3.3.5–3.3.7,3.4,3.8–3.9,3.14–3.15",
826 "CTM-LANDING",
827 "CTM-PREVIEW"
828 ],
829 "openQuestions": [
830 "Q-CTM",
831 "Q-ERRATA"
832 ],
833 "nextAction": "Keep NOT-RUN. Decide any documented corpus exception only after edition check; compatibility grammar would need separate authorization.",
834 "historicalIntent": {
835 "epistemicStatus": "hypothesized",
836 "claim": "The corpus may have assumed variable substitution in an additional SI tail position; no editor decision/erratum proving that intention was found."
837 },
838 "epistemicStatus": "derived",
839 "evidenceStrength": "explicit missing primary clause or interpretation; bounded conclusion from available sources"
840 }
841 ```
842
843 ## ctm/in/template-subject-identifier2.ctm
844
845 Vorher: normative-conflict / C. Neue Entscheidung: **C**. Registrierung unverändert: `not-run`.
846
847 Document IRI: `https://ctm-tests.example.invalid/cd165b150176c1d6842b37be9cc9051b40d4996b/ctm/in/template-subject-identifier2.ctm`.
848
849 Original: `vendor/cxtm/ctm/in/template-subject-identifier2.ctm`, 81 Bytes; SHA-256 `ffc9a5554b9c908386f6888ef29ccda5cc433e5519924db52f9441769e1df014`.
850
851 ```text
852
853 def template($iri)
854 topic $iri.
855 end
856
857 template(<http://psi.example.org/fake>)
858 ```
859
860 Quellabschluss: LF vorhanden. UTF-8-BOM: nein.
861
862 Unveränderte Baseline: `vendor/cxtm/ctm/baseline/template-subject-identifier2.ctm.cxtm`, 204 Bytes; SHA-256 `e138a02738dc4a2526c465b11fa6915bed84724a31748eb3578ddf0f8ab16253`.
863
864 ```xml
865 <topicMap>
866 <topic number="1">
867 <subjectIdentifiers>
868 <locator>http://psi.example.org/fake</locator>
869 </subjectIdentifiers>
870 <itemIdentifiers>
871 <locator>#topic</locator>
872 </itemIdentifiers>
873 </topic>
874 </topicMap>
875 ```
876
877 Tatsächliche Condition (einschließlich Code, Position und Cause):
878
879 ```json
880 {
881 "condition": "INVALID-TEMPLATE-BODY",
882 "message": "TEMPLATE-IDENTITY-TAIL in ctm/in/template-subject-identifier2.ctm at CHARACTER 34 (line 3, column 15): Unmarked variable identities in Topic Tails remain outside the supported grammar.",
883 "code": "template-identity-tail",
884 "position": 34,
885 "line": 3,
886 "column": 15,
887 "positionUnit": "character",
888 "source": "ctm/in/template-subject-identifier2.ctm",
889 "cause": null,
890 "context": null
891 }
892 ```
893
894 Kein natives Original-Ergebnismodell und keine Original-Ist-CXTM-Ausgabe; keine Ersatzmap konstruiert.
895
896 Erneut geprüfte Variablenpositionen, Deklaration, Aufrufe und Bindungen:
897
898 ```json
899 {
900 "variables": [
901 {
902 "variable": "$iri",
903 "position": 14,
904 "line": 2,
905 "column": 14,
906 "role": "Parameterdeklaration"
907 },
908 {
909 "variable": "$iri",
910 "position": 30,
911 "line": 3,
912 "column": 11,
913 "role": "Subject Identifier im Topic Tail (unmarkiert)"
914 }
915 ],
916 "declaration": "def template($iri)",
917 "bindings": [
918 [
919 "$iri",
920 "<http://psi.example.org/fake>"
921 ]
922 ],
923 "invocations": [
924 {
925 "text": "template(<http://psi.example.org/fake>)",
926 "position": 41,
927 "line": 6
928 }
929 ]
930 }
931 ```
932
933 Ausgeschriebene Gegenprobe (kein Original-PASS): 204/204 Bytes identisch; Condition null.
934
935 Neue normative Entscheidung und offene Primärquellen:
936
937 ```json
938 {
939 "classification": "C",
940 "scope": "Published-edition legality of unmarked additional SI variable in Topic Tail",
941 "claim": "The inspected HTML excludes this body position. The current condition occurs there before argument qualification; later published grammar has not been verified.",
942 "conditionalConclusion": "Body invalid under inspected HTML. The expanded control reproduces baseline bytes but does not validate the original template.",
943 "references": [
944 "CTM-HTML:3.3.5–3.3.7,3.4,3.8–3.9,3.14–3.15",
945 "CTM-LANDING",
946 "CTM-PREVIEW"
947 ],
948 "openQuestions": [
949 "Q-CTM",
950 "Q-ERRATA"
951 ],
952 "nextAction": "Keep NOT-RUN. Decide any documented corpus exception only after edition check; compatibility grammar would need separate authorization.",
953 "historicalIntent": {
954 "epistemicStatus": "hypothesized",
955 "claim": "The corpus may have assumed variable substitution in an additional SI tail position; no editor decision/erratum proving that intention was found."
956 },
957 "epistemicStatus": "derived",
958 "evidenceStrength": "explicit missing primary clause or interpretation; bounded conclusion from available sources"
959 }
960 ```
961
962 ## ctm/invalid/template-item-identifier-2nd-arg.ctm
963
964 Vorher: normative-conflict / C. Neue Entscheidung: **C**. Registrierung unverändert: `not-run`.
965
966 Document IRI: `https://ctm-tests.example.invalid/cd165b150176c1d6842b37be9cc9051b40d4996b/ctm/invalid/template-item-identifier-2nd-arg.ctm`.
967
968 Original: `vendor/cxtm/ctm/invalid/template-item-identifier-2nd-arg.ctm`, 167 Bytes; SHA-256 `ceb46d4457532cc5b432d5e601275cc6950bb105088e2b2ccfa4ffa5fbe82266`.
969
970 ```text
971
972 def template($iri1, $iri2)
973 topic1 $iri1.
974 topic2 $iri2.
975 end
976
977 template(<http://www.example.org/>, # valid
978 ^<http://www.example.org/>) # invalid
979 ```
980
981 Quellabschluss: LF vorhanden. UTF-8-BOM: nein.
982
983 Keine positive CXTM-Baseline für diesen negativen Syntaxvertrag.
984
985 Tatsächliche Condition (einschließlich Code, Position und Cause):
986
987 ```json
988 {
989 "condition": "INVALID-TEMPLATE-BODY",
990 "message": "TEMPLATE-IDENTITY-TAIL in ctm/invalid/template-item-identifier-2nd-arg.ctm at CHARACTER 44 (line 3, column 17): Unmarked variable identities in Topic Tails remain outside the supported grammar.",
991 "code": "template-identity-tail",
992 "position": 44,
993 "line": 3,
994 "column": 17,
995 "positionUnit": "character",
996 "source": "ctm/invalid/template-item-identifier-2nd-arg.ctm",
997 "cause": null,
998 "context": null
999 }
1000 ```
1001
1002 Kein natives Original-Ergebnismodell und keine Original-Ist-CXTM-Ausgabe; keine Ersatzmap konstruiert.
1003
1004 Erneut geprüfte Variablenpositionen, Deklaration, Aufrufe und Bindungen:
1005
1006 ```json
1007 {
1008 "variables": [
1009 {
1010 "variable": "$iri1",
1011 "position": 14,
1012 "line": 2,
1013 "column": 14,
1014 "role": "Parameterdeklaration"
1015 },
1016 {
1017 "variable": "$iri2",
1018 "position": 21,
1019 "line": 2,
1020 "column": 21,
1021 "role": "Parameterdeklaration"
1022 },
1023 {
1024 "variable": "$iri1",
1025 "position": 39,
1026 "line": 3,
1027 "column": 12,
1028 "role": "Subject Identifier von topic1 (unmarkiert)"
1029 },
1030 {
1031 "variable": "$iri2",
1032 "position": 57,
1033 "line": 4,
1034 "column": 12,
1035 "role": "Subject Identifier von topic2 (unmarkiert)"
1036 }
1037 ],
1038 "declaration": "def template($iri1, $iri2)",
1039 "bindings": [
1040 [
1041 "$iri1",
1042 "<http://www.example.org/>"
1043 ],
1044 [
1045 "$iri2",
1046 "^<http://www.example.org/>"
1047 ]
1048 ],
1049 "invocations": [
1050 {
1051 "text": "template(<http://www.example.org/>, # valid\n ^<http://www.example.org/>)",
1052 "position": 69,
1053 "line": 7
1054 }
1055 ]
1056 }
1057 ```
1058
1059 Historisch beabsichtigte, tatsächlich nicht erreichte Argumentprüfung:
1060
1061 ```json
1062 {
1063 "argumentPosition": 2,
1064 "marker": "^",
1065 "cause": "Argument 2 mit ^ ist für den beabsichtigten unmarkierten SI-Verwendungskontext ungeeignet.",
1066 "currentlyReached": false,
1067 "actualBlockingCause": "INVALID-TEMPLATE-BODY/:template-identity-tail",
1068 "evidence": "Originalkörper und markiertes Argument; bei 2nd-arg Originalkommentar valid/invalid."
1069 }
1070 ```
1071
1072 Neue normative Entscheidung und offene Primärquellen:
1073
1074 ```json
1075 {
1076 "classification": "C",
1077 "scope": "Published-edition legality of unmarked additional SI variable in Topic Tail",
1078 "claim": "The inspected HTML excludes this body position. The current condition occurs there before argument qualification; later published grammar has not been verified.",
1079 "conditionalConclusion": "Body invalid under inspected HTML. This does not qualify the historical argument-rejection contract.",
1080 "references": [
1081 "CTM-HTML:3.3.5–3.3.7,3.4,3.8–3.9,3.14–3.15",
1082 "CTM-LANDING",
1083 "CTM-PREVIEW"
1084 ],
1085 "openQuestions": [
1086 "Q-CTM",
1087 "Q-ERRATA"
1088 ],
1089 "nextAction": "Keep NOT-RUN. A body-syntax negative acceptance contract would require a separate agreement even if final grammar confirms exclusion.",
1090 "historicalIntent": {
1091 "epistemicStatus": "hypothesized",
1092 "claim": "The corpus may have assumed variable substitution in an additional SI tail position; no editor decision/erratum proving that intention was found."
1093 },
1094 "epistemicStatus": "derived",
1095 "evidenceStrength": "explicit missing primary clause or interpretation; bounded conclusion from available sources"
1096 }
1097 ```
1098
1099 ## ctm/invalid/template-item-identifier3.ctm
1100
1101 Vorher: normative-conflict / C. Neue Entscheidung: **C**. Registrierung unverändert: `not-run`.
1102
1103 Document IRI: `https://ctm-tests.example.invalid/cd165b150176c1d6842b37be9cc9051b40d4996b/ctm/invalid/template-item-identifier3.ctm`.
1104
1105 Original: `vendor/cxtm/ctm/invalid/template-item-identifier3.ctm`, 78 Bytes; SHA-256 `4c7ed0ab1574462b8939379f745a28942aa380fc6cc7fabae597fdc7bb21225f`.
1106
1107 ```text
1108
1109 def template($iri)
1110 topic $iri.
1111 end
1112
1113 template(^<http://www.example.org/>)
1114 ```
1115
1116 Quellabschluss: LF vorhanden. UTF-8-BOM: nein.
1117
1118 Keine positive CXTM-Baseline für diesen negativen Syntaxvertrag.
1119
1120 Tatsächliche Condition (einschließlich Code, Position und Cause):
1121
1122 ```json
1123 {
1124 "condition": "INVALID-TEMPLATE-BODY",
1125 "message": "TEMPLATE-IDENTITY-TAIL in ctm/invalid/template-item-identifier3.ctm at CHARACTER 34 (line 3, column 15): Unmarked variable identities in Topic Tails remain outside the supported grammar.",
1126 "code": "template-identity-tail",
1127 "position": 34,
1128 "line": 3,
1129 "column": 15,
1130 "positionUnit": "character",
1131 "source": "ctm/invalid/template-item-identifier3.ctm",
1132 "cause": null,
1133 "context": null
1134 }
1135 ```
1136
1137 Kein natives Original-Ergebnismodell und keine Original-Ist-CXTM-Ausgabe; keine Ersatzmap konstruiert.
1138
1139 Erneut geprüfte Variablenpositionen, Deklaration, Aufrufe und Bindungen:
1140
1141 ```json
1142 {
1143 "variables": [
1144 {
1145 "variable": "$iri",
1146 "position": 14,
1147 "line": 2,
1148 "column": 14,
1149 "role": "Parameterdeklaration"
1150 },
1151 {
1152 "variable": "$iri",
1153 "position": 30,
1154 "line": 3,
1155 "column": 11,
1156 "role": "Subject Identifier von topic (unmarkiert)"
1157 }
1158 ],
1159 "declaration": "def template($iri)",
1160 "bindings": [
1161 [
1162 "$iri",
1163 "^<http://www.example.org/>"
1164 ]
1165 ],
1166 "invocations": [
1167 {
1168 "text": "template(^<http://www.example.org/>)",
1169 "position": 41,
1170 "line": 6
1171 }
1172 ]
1173 }
1174 ```
1175
1176 Historisch beabsichtigte, tatsächlich nicht erreichte Argumentprüfung:
1177
1178 ```json
1179 {
1180 "argumentPosition": 1,
1181 "marker": "^",
1182 "cause": "Argument 1 mit ^ ist für den beabsichtigten unmarkierten SI-Verwendungskontext ungeeignet.",
1183 "currentlyReached": false,
1184 "actualBlockingCause": "INVALID-TEMPLATE-BODY/:template-identity-tail",
1185 "evidence": "Originalkörper und markiertes Argument; bei 2nd-arg Originalkommentar valid/invalid."
1186 }
1187 ```
1188
1189 Neue normative Entscheidung und offene Primärquellen:
1190
1191 ```json
1192 {
1193 "classification": "C",
1194 "scope": "Published-edition legality of unmarked additional SI variable in Topic Tail",
1195 "claim": "The inspected HTML excludes this body position. The current condition occurs there before argument qualification; later published grammar has not been verified.",
1196 "conditionalConclusion": "Body invalid under inspected HTML. This does not qualify the historical argument-rejection contract.",
1197 "references": [
1198 "CTM-HTML:3.3.5–3.3.7,3.4,3.8–3.9,3.14–3.15",
1199 "CTM-LANDING",
1200 "CTM-PREVIEW"
1201 ],
1202 "openQuestions": [
1203 "Q-CTM",
1204 "Q-ERRATA"
1205 ],
1206 "nextAction": "Keep NOT-RUN. A body-syntax negative acceptance contract would require a separate agreement even if final grammar confirms exclusion.",
1207 "historicalIntent": {
1208 "epistemicStatus": "hypothesized",
1209 "claim": "The corpus may have assumed variable substitution in an additional SI tail position; no editor decision/erratum proving that intention was found."
1210 },
1211 "epistemicStatus": "derived",
1212 "evidenceStrength": "explicit missing primary clause or interpretation; bounded conclusion from available sources"
1213 }
1214 ```
1215
1216 ## ctm/invalid/template-subject-locator-2nd-arg.ctm
1217
1218 Vorher: normative-conflict / C. Neue Entscheidung: **C**. Registrierung unverändert: `not-run`.
1219
1220 Document IRI: `https://ctm-tests.example.invalid/cd165b150176c1d6842b37be9cc9051b40d4996b/ctm/invalid/template-subject-locator-2nd-arg.ctm`.
1221
1222 Original: `vendor/cxtm/ctm/invalid/template-subject-locator-2nd-arg.ctm`, 167 Bytes; SHA-256 `e7e8ca08ad1dec89549afbe2d3cf90098269031f239ddae37258bf87ba4c018f`.
1223
1224 ```text
1225
1226 def template($iri1, $iri2)
1227 topic1 $iri1.
1228 topic2 $iri2.
1229 end
1230
1231 template(<http://www.example.org/>, # valid
1232 =<http://www.example.org/>) # invalid
1233 ```
1234
1235 Quellabschluss: LF vorhanden. UTF-8-BOM: nein.
1236
1237 Keine positive CXTM-Baseline für diesen negativen Syntaxvertrag.
1238
1239 Tatsächliche Condition (einschließlich Code, Position und Cause):
1240
1241 ```json
1242 {
1243 "condition": "INVALID-TEMPLATE-BODY",
1244 "message": "TEMPLATE-IDENTITY-TAIL in ctm/invalid/template-subject-locator-2nd-arg.ctm at CHARACTER 44 (line 3, column 17): Unmarked variable identities in Topic Tails remain outside the supported grammar.",
1245 "code": "template-identity-tail",
1246 "position": 44,
1247 "line": 3,
1248 "column": 17,
1249 "positionUnit": "character",
1250 "source": "ctm/invalid/template-subject-locator-2nd-arg.ctm",
1251 "cause": null,
1252 "context": null
1253 }
1254 ```
1255
1256 Kein natives Original-Ergebnismodell und keine Original-Ist-CXTM-Ausgabe; keine Ersatzmap konstruiert.
1257
1258 Erneut geprüfte Variablenpositionen, Deklaration, Aufrufe und Bindungen:
1259
1260 ```json
1261 {
1262 "variables": [
1263 {
1264 "variable": "$iri1",
1265 "position": 14,
1266 "line": 2,
1267 "column": 14,
1268 "role": "Parameterdeklaration"
1269 },
1270 {
1271 "variable": "$iri2",
1272 "position": 21,
1273 "line": 2,
1274 "column": 21,
1275 "role": "Parameterdeklaration"
1276 },
1277 {
1278 "variable": "$iri1",
1279 "position": 39,
1280 "line": 3,
1281 "column": 12,
1282 "role": "Subject Identifier von topic1 (unmarkiert)"
1283 },
1284 {
1285 "variable": "$iri2",
1286 "position": 57,
1287 "line": 4,
1288 "column": 12,
1289 "role": "Subject Identifier von topic2 (unmarkiert)"
1290 }
1291 ],
1292 "declaration": "def template($iri1, $iri2)",
1293 "bindings": [
1294 [
1295 "$iri1",
1296 "<http://www.example.org/>"
1297 ],
1298 [
1299 "$iri2",
1300 "=<http://www.example.org/>"
1301 ]
1302 ],
1303 "invocations": [
1304 {
1305 "text": "template(<http://www.example.org/>, # valid\n =<http://www.example.org/>)",
1306 "position": 69,
1307 "line": 7
1308 }
1309 ]
1310 }
1311 ```
1312
1313 Historisch beabsichtigte, tatsächlich nicht erreichte Argumentprüfung:
1314
1315 ```json
1316 {
1317 "argumentPosition": 2,
1318 "marker": "=",
1319 "cause": "Argument 2 mit = ist für den beabsichtigten unmarkierten SI-Verwendungskontext ungeeignet.",
1320 "currentlyReached": false,
1321 "actualBlockingCause": "INVALID-TEMPLATE-BODY/:template-identity-tail",
1322 "evidence": "Originalkörper und markiertes Argument; bei 2nd-arg Originalkommentar valid/invalid."
1323 }
1324 ```
1325
1326 Neue normative Entscheidung und offene Primärquellen:
1327
1328 ```json
1329 {
1330 "classification": "C",
1331 "scope": "Published-edition legality of unmarked additional SI variable in Topic Tail",
1332 "claim": "The inspected HTML excludes this body position. The current condition occurs there before argument qualification; later published grammar has not been verified.",
1333 "conditionalConclusion": "Body invalid under inspected HTML. This does not qualify the historical argument-rejection contract.",
1334 "references": [
1335 "CTM-HTML:3.3.5–3.3.7,3.4,3.8–3.9,3.14–3.15",
1336 "CTM-LANDING",
1337 "CTM-PREVIEW"
1338 ],
1339 "openQuestions": [
1340 "Q-CTM",
1341 "Q-ERRATA"
1342 ],
1343 "nextAction": "Keep NOT-RUN. A body-syntax negative acceptance contract would require a separate agreement even if final grammar confirms exclusion.",
1344 "historicalIntent": {
1345 "epistemicStatus": "hypothesized",
1346 "claim": "The corpus may have assumed variable substitution in an additional SI tail position; no editor decision/erratum proving that intention was found."
1347 },
1348 "epistemicStatus": "derived",
1349 "evidenceStrength": "explicit missing primary clause or interpretation; bounded conclusion from available sources"
1350 }
1351 ```
1352
1353 ## ctm/invalid/template-subject-locator3.ctm
1354
1355 Vorher: normative-conflict / C. Neue Entscheidung: **C**. Registrierung unverändert: `not-run`.
1356
1357 Document IRI: `https://ctm-tests.example.invalid/cd165b150176c1d6842b37be9cc9051b40d4996b/ctm/invalid/template-subject-locator3.ctm`.
1358
1359 Original: `vendor/cxtm/ctm/invalid/template-subject-locator3.ctm`, 78 Bytes; SHA-256 `d53c835df922469d65e5103f48b38faa94be56c06a4cb1da356a8ad6b277496d`.
1360
1361 ```text
1362
1363 def template($iri)
1364 topic $iri.
1365 end
1366
1367 template(=<http://www.example.org/>)
1368 ```
1369
1370 Quellabschluss: LF vorhanden. UTF-8-BOM: nein.
1371
1372 Keine positive CXTM-Baseline für diesen negativen Syntaxvertrag.
1373
1374 Tatsächliche Condition (einschließlich Code, Position und Cause):
1375
1376 ```json
1377 {
1378 "condition": "INVALID-TEMPLATE-BODY",
1379 "message": "TEMPLATE-IDENTITY-TAIL in ctm/invalid/template-subject-locator3.ctm at CHARACTER 34 (line 3, column 15): Unmarked variable identities in Topic Tails remain outside the supported grammar.",
1380 "code": "template-identity-tail",
1381 "position": 34,
1382 "line": 3,
1383 "column": 15,
1384 "positionUnit": "character",
1385 "source": "ctm/invalid/template-subject-locator3.ctm",
1386 "cause": null,
1387 "context": null
1388 }
1389 ```
1390
1391 Kein natives Original-Ergebnismodell und keine Original-Ist-CXTM-Ausgabe; keine Ersatzmap konstruiert.
1392
1393 Erneut geprüfte Variablenpositionen, Deklaration, Aufrufe und Bindungen:
1394
1395 ```json
1396 {
1397 "variables": [
1398 {
1399 "variable": "$iri",
1400 "position": 14,
1401 "line": 2,
1402 "column": 14,
1403 "role": "Parameterdeklaration"
1404 },
1405 {
1406 "variable": "$iri",
1407 "position": 30,
1408 "line": 3,
1409 "column": 11,
1410 "role": "Subject Identifier von topic (unmarkiert)"
1411 }
1412 ],
1413 "declaration": "def template($iri)",
1414 "bindings": [
1415 [
1416 "$iri",
1417 "=<http://www.example.org/>"
1418 ]
1419 ],
1420 "invocations": [
1421 {
1422 "text": "template(=<http://www.example.org/>)",
1423 "position": 41,
1424 "line": 6
1425 }
1426 ]
1427 }
1428 ```
1429
1430 Historisch beabsichtigte, tatsächlich nicht erreichte Argumentprüfung:
1431
1432 ```json
1433 {
1434 "argumentPosition": 1,
1435 "marker": "=",
1436 "cause": "Argument 1 mit = ist für den beabsichtigten unmarkierten SI-Verwendungskontext ungeeignet.",
1437 "currentlyReached": false,
1438 "actualBlockingCause": "INVALID-TEMPLATE-BODY/:template-identity-tail",
1439 "evidence": "Originalkörper und markiertes Argument; bei 2nd-arg Originalkommentar valid/invalid."
1440 }
1441 ```
1442
1443 Neue normative Entscheidung und offene Primärquellen:
1444
1445 ```json
1446 {
1447 "classification": "C",
1448 "scope": "Published-edition legality of unmarked additional SI variable in Topic Tail",
1449 "claim": "The inspected HTML excludes this body position. The current condition occurs there before argument qualification; later published grammar has not been verified.",
1450 "conditionalConclusion": "Body invalid under inspected HTML. This does not qualify the historical argument-rejection contract.",
1451 "references": [
1452 "CTM-HTML:3.3.5–3.3.7,3.4,3.8–3.9,3.14–3.15",
1453 "CTM-LANDING",
1454 "CTM-PREVIEW"
1455 ],
1456 "openQuestions": [
1457 "Q-CTM",
1458 "Q-ERRATA"
1459 ],
1460 "nextAction": "Keep NOT-RUN. A body-syntax negative acceptance contract would require a separate agreement even if final grammar confirms exclusion.",
1461 "historicalIntent": {
1462 "epistemicStatus": "hypothesized",
1463 "claim": "The corpus may have assumed variable substitution in an additional SI tail position; no editor decision/erratum proving that intention was found."
1464 },
1465 "epistemicStatus": "derived",
1466 "evidenceStrength": "explicit missing primary clause or interpretation; bounded conclusion from available sources"
1467 }
1468 ```
1469
1470 ## xtm2/in/mergemap-itemid.xtm
1471
1472 Vorher: normative-conflict / C. Neue Entscheidung: **A**. Registrierung unverändert: `not-run`.
1473
1474 Document IRI: `https://xtm-tests.example.invalid/cd165b150176c1d6842b37be9cc9051b40d4996b/xtm2/in/mergemap-itemid.xtm`.
1475
1476 Original: `vendor/cxtm/xtm2/in/mergemap-itemid.xtm`, 148 Bytes; SHA-256 `23de617d6e201374ec3f9c12e02be88bc555dd7dbcd262e854c8e9a3f96966d1`.
1477
1478 ```xml
1479 <topicMap xmlns="http://www.topicmaps.org/xtm/" version="2.0">
1480 <mergeMap href="mergemap-itemid.sub"/>
1481 <topic id="topic">
1482 </topic>
1483 </topicMap>
1484 ```
1485
1486 Quellabschluss: LF vorhanden. UTF-8-BOM: nein.
1487
1488 Unveränderte Baseline: `vendor/cxtm/xtm2/baseline/mergemap-itemid.xtm.cxtm`, 314 Bytes; SHA-256 `03c5c1694e572674c0982f3b01d8c2fb323159ba6436857924814ea1e7a2d5d7`.
1489
1490 ```xml
1491 <topicMap>
1492 <itemIdentifiers>
1493 <locator>mergemap-itemid.sub#the-topic-map</locator>
1494 </itemIdentifiers>
1495 <topic number="1">
1496 <itemIdentifiers>
1497 <locator>#topic</locator>
1498 </itemIdentifiers>
1499 </topic>
1500 <topic number="2">
1501 <itemIdentifiers>
1502 <locator>mergemap-itemid.sub#topic</locator>
1503 </itemIdentifiers>
1504 </topic>
1505 </topicMap>
1506 ```
1507
1508 Tatsächliche Condition (einschließlich Code, Position und Cause):
1509
1510 ```json
1511 {
1512 "class": "XTM-UNSUPPORTED",
1513 "code": "unsupported-construct",
1514 "detail": "XTM mergeMap is not implemented in this subset.",
1515 "message": "XTM UNSUPPORTED-CONSTRUCT at xtm2/in/mergemap-itemid.xtm (https://xtm-tests.example.invalid/cd165b150176c1d6842b37be9cc9051b40d4996b/xtm2/in/mergemap-itemid.xtm), approximately 2:41: XTM mergeMap is not implemented in this subset.",
1516 "line": 2,
1517 "column": 41,
1518 "positionUnit": "approximate-SAX-line-column",
1519 "documentIRI": "https://xtm-tests.example.invalid/cd165b150176c1d6842b37be9cc9051b40d4996b/xtm2/in/mergemap-itemid.xtm",
1520 "sourceKey": "xtm2/in/mergemap-itemid.xtm",
1521 "cause": null
1522 }
1523 ```
1524
1525 Kein natives Original-Ergebnismodell und keine Original-Ist-CXTM-Ausgabe; keine Ersatzmap konstruiert.
1526
1527 Unveränderte Hilfsquelle: `vendor/cxtm/xtm2/in/mergemap-itemid.sub`, 151 Bytes; SHA-256 `20cfc5dafa42543648b9f3ee4f41434f56f7fe7679afb0f4a1c870bde2415c01`.
1528
1529 ```xml
1530 <topicMap xmlns="http://www.topicmaps.org/xtm/" version="2.0">
1531 <itemIdentity href="#the-topic-map"/>
1532 <topic id="topic">
1533 </topic>
1534 </topicMap>
1535 ```
1536
1537 Tatsächlicher Ressourcen-Referenzgraph:
1538
1539 ```json
1540 [
1541 {
1542 "fromDocumentIRI": "https://xtm-tests.example.invalid/cd165b150176c1d6842b37be9cc9051b40d4996b/xtm2/in/mergemap-itemid.xtm",
1543 "href": "mergemap-itemid.sub",
1544 "toDocumentIRI": "https://xtm-tests.example.invalid/cd165b150176c1d6842b37be9cc9051b40d4996b/xtm2/in/mergemap-itemid.sub"
1545 }
1546 ]
1547 ```
1548
1549 Separate Hilfsquellenbeobachtung, keine Originalregistrierung:
1550
1551 ```json
1552 [
1553 {
1554 "id": "xtm2/in/mergemap-itemid.sub",
1555 "kind": "auxiliary-source-only-not-an-original-contract",
1556 "documentIRI": "https://xtm-tests.example.invalid/cd165b150176c1d6842b37be9cc9051b40d4996b/xtm2/in/mergemap-itemid.sub",
1557 "sourceHex": "3C746F7069634D617020786D6C6E733D22687474703A2F2F7777772E746F7069636D6170732E6F72672F78746D2F222076657273696F6E3D22322E30223E0A20203C6974656D4964656E7469747920687265663D22237468652D746F7069632D6D6170222F3E0A20203C746F7069632069643D22746F706963223E202020200A20203C2F746F7069633E0A3C2F746F7069634D61703E0A",
1558 "sourceBytes": 151,
1559 "condition": null,
1560 "nativeModel": {
1561 "topicCount": 1,
1562 "associationCount": 0,
1563 "canonicalParentsAndInverseReferences": true,
1564 "topics": [
1565 {
1566 "ordinal": 1,
1567 "itemIdentifiers": [
1568 "https://xtm-tests.example.invalid/cd165b150176c1d6842b37be9cc9051b40d4996b/xtm2/in/mergemap-itemid.sub#topic"
1569 ],
1570 "subjectIdentifiers": [],
1571 "subjectLocators": []
1572 }
1573 ],
1574 "associations": []
1575 },
1576 "mapItemIdentifiers": [
1577 "https://xtm-tests.example.invalid/cd165b150176c1d6842b37be9cc9051b40d4996b/xtm2/in/mergemap-itemid.sub#the-topic-map"
1578 ],
1579 "actualCXTM": "<topicMap>\n<itemIdentifiers>\n<locator>#the-topic-map</locator>\n</itemIdentifiers>\n<topic number=\"1\">\n<itemIdentifiers>\n<locator>#topic</locator>\n</itemIdentifiers>\n</topic>\n</topicMap>\n",
1580 "actualBytes": 185,
1581 "canonicalizationPreservesMap": true,
1582 "referencesCurrent": true
1583 }
1584 ]
1585 ```
1586
1587 Neue normative Entscheidung und offene Primärquellen:
1588
1589 ```json
1590 {
1591 "classification": "A",
1592 "scope": "Missing non-cyclic XTM mergeMap operation, not a claim that the baseline is fully normative",
1593 "claim": "The conforming non-cyclic source and available subresource require content import. The current reader rejects mergeMap before returning a model.",
1594 "references": [
1595 "XTM-HTML:4.2,4.4–4.6,4.21,5",
1596 "TMDM-HTML:5.1,5.2,5.3.5,6.1–6.2"
1597 ],
1598 "openQuestions": [
1599 "Q-ERRATA"
1600 ],
1601 "minimalCorrection": "In a separately authorized 22H, resolve pinned child bytes using the child Document IRI and native content import; preserve topic identifiers and target-map identity. No root-map II transfer solely for baseline matching.",
1602 "baselineAspect": {
1603 "epistemicStatus": "derived",
1604 "claim": "The expected child map II is outside the 4.21 import operands. Child model proves that this II belongs to the child Map, not its Topic. No current successful original model exists, so calling the whole case B would fail the requested B definition."
1605 },
1606 "nextAction": "Plan normative mergeMap support separately; its result may still disagree with this historical baseline. Do not forecast this original as an unconditional PASS.",
1607 "changeFrom22A": "Resolves the absent non-cyclic import as A using publication-identical declared XTM text; isolates the baseline root-II conflict rather than treating unsupported as an acceptable B result.",
1608 "epistemicStatus": "derived",
1609 "evidenceStrength": "publication-identical declared public XTM/TMDM plus fresh execution"
1610 }
1611 ```
1612
1613 ## xtm2/in/mergemap-loop.xtm
1614
1615 Vorher: unresolved-requirement / C. Neue Entscheidung: **C**. Registrierung unverändert: `not-run`.
1616
1617 Document IRI: `https://xtm-tests.example.invalid/cd165b150176c1d6842b37be9cc9051b40d4996b/xtm2/in/mergemap-loop.xtm`.
1618
1619 Original: `vendor/cxtm/xtm2/in/mergemap-loop.xtm`, 150 Bytes; SHA-256 `033f5191ccfa3af9382a9cc6c47720f9b63b990f9485f10c3d2ac8d113b1cedb`.
1620
1621 ```xml
1622 <topicMap xmlns="http://www.topicmaps.org/xtm/" version="2.0">
1623 <mergeMap href="mergemap-loop.sub"/>
1624 <topic id="topic">
1625 </topic>
1626 </topicMap>
1627 ```
1628
1629 Quellabschluss: LF vorhanden. UTF-8-BOM: nein.
1630
1631 Unveränderte Baseline: `vendor/cxtm/xtm2/baseline/mergemap-loop.xtm.cxtm`, 222 Bytes; SHA-256 `f0f56a0e2cf22ba274b6f10ef20cd128841908ed0f3e10de3b67b218c394fc6f`.
1632
1633 ```xml
1634 <topicMap>
1635 <topic number="1">
1636 <itemIdentifiers>
1637 <locator>#topic</locator>
1638 </itemIdentifiers>
1639 </topic>
1640 <topic number="2">
1641 <itemIdentifiers>
1642 <locator>mergemap-loop.sub#topic</locator>
1643 </itemIdentifiers>
1644 </topic>
1645 </topicMap>
1646 ```
1647
1648 Tatsächliche Condition (einschließlich Code, Position und Cause):
1649
1650 ```json
1651 {
1652 "class": "XTM-UNSUPPORTED",
1653 "code": "unsupported-construct",
1654 "detail": "XTM mergeMap is not implemented in this subset.",
1655 "message": "XTM UNSUPPORTED-CONSTRUCT at xtm2/in/mergemap-loop.xtm (https://xtm-tests.example.invalid/cd165b150176c1d6842b37be9cc9051b40d4996b/xtm2/in/mergemap-loop.xtm), approximately 2:39: XTM mergeMap is not implemented in this subset.",
1656 "line": 2,
1657 "column": 39,
1658 "positionUnit": "approximate-SAX-line-column",
1659 "documentIRI": "https://xtm-tests.example.invalid/cd165b150176c1d6842b37be9cc9051b40d4996b/xtm2/in/mergemap-loop.xtm",
1660 "sourceKey": "xtm2/in/mergemap-loop.xtm",
1661 "cause": null
1662 }
1663 ```
1664
1665 Kein natives Original-Ergebnismodell und keine Original-Ist-CXTM-Ausgabe; keine Ersatzmap konstruiert.
1666
1667 Unveränderte Hilfsquelle: `vendor/cxtm/xtm2/in/mergemap-loop.sub`, 150 Bytes; SHA-256 `94e4a9ac5ea85c2f5025cf8feff5e8eb62f5981795b0d19a8a64af1b2f69835c`.
1668
1669 ```xml
1670 <topicMap xmlns="http://www.topicmaps.org/xtm/" version="2.0">
1671 <mergeMap href="mergemap-loop.xtm"/>
1672 <topic id="topic">
1673 </topic>
1674 </topicMap>
1675 ```
1676
1677 Tatsächlicher Ressourcen-Referenzgraph:
1678
1679 ```json
1680 [
1681 {
1682 "fromDocumentIRI": "https://xtm-tests.example.invalid/cd165b150176c1d6842b37be9cc9051b40d4996b/xtm2/in/mergemap-loop.xtm",
1683 "href": "mergemap-loop.sub",
1684 "toDocumentIRI": "https://xtm-tests.example.invalid/cd165b150176c1d6842b37be9cc9051b40d4996b/xtm2/in/mergemap-loop.sub"
1685 },
1686 {
1687 "fromDocumentIRI": "https://xtm-tests.example.invalid/cd165b150176c1d6842b37be9cc9051b40d4996b/xtm2/in/mergemap-loop.sub",
1688 "href": "mergemap-loop.xtm",
1689 "toDocumentIRI": "https://xtm-tests.example.invalid/cd165b150176c1d6842b37be9cc9051b40d4996b/xtm2/in/mergemap-loop.xtm"
1690 }
1691 ]
1692 ```
1693
1694 Separate Hilfsquellenbeobachtung, keine Originalregistrierung:
1695
1696 ```json
1697 [
1698 {
1699 "id": "xtm2/in/mergemap-loop.sub",
1700 "kind": "auxiliary-source-only-not-an-original-contract",
1701 "documentIRI": "https://xtm-tests.example.invalid/cd165b150176c1d6842b37be9cc9051b40d4996b/xtm2/in/mergemap-loop.sub",
1702 "sourceHex": "3C746F7069634D617020786D6C6E733D22687474703A2F2F7777772E746F7069636D6170732E6F72672F78746D2F222076657273696F6E3D22322E30223E0A20203C6D657267654D617020687265663D226D657267656D61702D6C6F6F702E78746D222F3E0A20203C746F7069632069643D22746F706963223E202020200A20203C2F746F7069633E0A3C2F746F7069634D61703E0A",
1703 "sourceBytes": 150,
1704 "condition": {
1705 "class": "XTM-UNSUPPORTED",
1706 "code": "unsupported-construct",
1707 "detail": "XTM mergeMap is not implemented in this subset.",
1708 "message": "XTM UNSUPPORTED-CONSTRUCT at xtm2/in/mergemap-loop.sub (https://xtm-tests.example.invalid/cd165b150176c1d6842b37be9cc9051b40d4996b/xtm2/in/mergemap-loop.sub), approximately 2:39: XTM mergeMap is not implemented in this subset.",
1709 "line": 2,
1710 "column": 39,
1711 "positionUnit": "approximate-SAX-line-column",
1712 "documentIRI": "https://xtm-tests.example.invalid/cd165b150176c1d6842b37be9cc9051b40d4996b/xtm2/in/mergemap-loop.sub",
1713 "sourceKey": "xtm2/in/mergemap-loop.sub",
1714 "cause": null
1715 },
1716 "nativeModel": null,
1717 "mapItemIdentifiers": null,
1718 "actualCXTM": null,
1719 "actualBytes": null,
1720 "canonicalizationPreservesMap": null,
1721 "referencesCurrent": null
1722 }
1723 ]
1724 ```
1725
1726 Neue normative Entscheidung und offene Primärquellen:
1727
1728 ```json
1729 {
1730 "classification": "C",
1731 "scope": "Cyclic deserialization semantics and finite model completion",
1732 "claim": "Root and subresource reference each other before their local Topic. The current rejection is unsupported, not cycle handling. The inspected rules do not prescribe a repeated-document cache or cycle error.",
1733 "references": [
1734 "XTM-HTML:4.2,4.21,5",
1735 "TMDM-HTML:5.3.5,6.1–6.2"
1736 ],
1737 "openQuestions": [
1738 "Q-XTM-LOOP",
1739 "Q-ERRATA"
1740 ],
1741 "conditionalConclusion": "A finite closure retaining both document-qualified topic identifiers is consistent with the baseline; its operational derivation needs explicit qualification.",
1742 "nextAction": "Separately approve a finite resolver/graph-completion acceptance contract before implementing or registering this cyclic original.",
1743 "epistemicStatus": "derived",
1744 "evidenceStrength": "explicit missing primary clause or interpretation; bounded conclusion from available sources"
1745 }
1746 ```